I agree
Voting is Disabled

13 votes

I disagree

Rank2436

Idea#4185

This idea is active.
Legal & Policy Challenges »

Americans with Disabilities architectural requirements

Why Is This Idea Important?: Many worthwile projects will never get accomplished because the existing conditions are "grandfathered in" and the threatened cost will even deter people from making needed upgrades to their buildings -- especially in California where there are a abundance of regulators and litigants with little to do. The homebound, such as my late mother would never have benefitted from any of the ADA provisions, because pain limited her ability to lift a phone in the 1960's. Vietnam war wounded often benefit as have those people with strong lobbying affiliations -- such as polio victims in Minnesota, but no where else in the world. I would quit my job as a longtime architect at a Dow 30 Company if given an opportunity, for out of pocket expenses perhaps, if I could lead an unbiased team to fix these rules to actually benefit the disabled community as a whole, and end the waste and associated disgust. Our company once had to spent $20,000 extra to build a custom, oversized revolving door into a drug manufacturing cleanroom to allow access by people in wheelchairs. However, the FDA protocol prohibited wheelchairs from the area because of drug contamination issues. This was a highly visible and assinine waste of money and there are so many similar mandates it should be an embarrassment. Had my firm been required to spend the $20,000 on something beneficial, the company would have contributed to solving a problem instead of throwing away design time, construction effort, and state review money. Only a deeply entrenched bureaucracy, with specific beneficiaries having an axe to grind could be so selfish as not to have comprehended the problem I am addressing. The flagrant overkill and the corresponding failures where access ought to be provided are proof of government failure involving every non-residential building in the country -- of course church sanctuaries are exempted. The fact that perishioners cannot attend their church or sing in the choir or stand at a pulpit because of a disability is the ultimate irony and injury. Some exemption.

This 20 year old act with some minor proposals in the past year is in need of major revision. Money that is being forced to be spent on specific mandated projects that will never likely benefit anyone, could instead be collected and put in a pool to fund projects that actually would benefit disabled persons.

Submitted by stevedelapp 2 years ago

Vote Activity Show

Comments (6)

  1. apugh96 said:

    Disability architecture is usally constructed using the minimum requirements. Bathrooms are the worst! They rarely have bars on both sides of the toilet (necessary for balance) or vertical bars. They were definitely not designed by someone who would use them, none of it is. But it is expensive and the building owner is paying a lot for little reward. I'm in a wheelchair and I have difficulty standing without these bars. Even medical buildings rarely have them.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  2. Big Rooster said:

    I would have no problem with that. I would rather see our money going to that instead some damn mouse that lives by a lake in San Francisco or an underground turtle crossing in Florida.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  3. apugh96 said:

    Thanks Rooster.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  4. Big Rooster said:

    I have never had a problem helping anyone that truely needs it or if it would just make their life a little more easy for them...I am all in for that.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  5. joemck85 said:

    What does an underground turtle crossing have to do with the Americans with Disabilities Act?

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  6. Big Rooster said:

    "I would rather see our money going to that instead some damn mouse that lives by a lake in San Francisco or an underground turtle crossing in Florida."..read this again...slowly.

    I said a good thing...ok?

    2 years ago
    0
    0