Open Government Dialogue
« Back To OpenGov - Open Government Brainstorm
Prohibit agencies from canceling FOIA requests
Agencies regularly send out letters to requesters saying, "Your request has been pending for so long that we wonder if you still want us to answer it. If you don't reply, we will pretend you never filed this FOIA request." This lets them sneakily evade requests.

It's fine for agencies to ask requesters if they'd like to voluntarily cancel their FOIA requests. What isn't fine is for agencies to cancel the requests without ever hearing from the requester. If the agency gets no response to its inquiry, it should continue processing the FOIA request.

Why Is This Idea Important?

Requests shouldn't get canceled because the requester went on vacation or was otherwise too busy to respond to the agency. A legal request was made; the requester never rescinded it; the agency is on the hook to respond. Period. You should not have to keep "justifying" your request to the agency every few months.
Comments
FOIA needs complete reworking. It is being abused by foreign governments (including Israel, France, and Germany as well as China) and by corporations to obtain information they have no right to. FOIA should be limited to individual citizens, and ONLY the citizens concerned or their legally designated representative should be able to make absolute demands for disclosure, including to the classified databases of the US intelligence community.
prsn12388 9 months ago
I agree that FOIA needs a complete overhaul. And while it may be unnerving to have info sent to places like China or internal documents sent to a corporation, transparency is transparency. In the day of the Internet, you can't have transparency for some people and not others.
Related Topics/Ideas
Title
Public FOIA archive on every agency website

Place Everything Public Online Unless the Law Says Otherwise

Transparency Ombudsman

set a time limit for classification review on new classified records

Centralized Digital System for FOIA Requests

Direct agencies to use online communications tools to help resolve disputes over FOIA requests.

Make documents produced by government contractors in their role as gov't surrogates subject to FOIA

Use their FOIA logs to identify types or categories of information & post that information online without waiting for a FOIA req

Real penalties for agencies that violate FOIA time limits

Government-wide Leadership, Implementation, and Enforcement on Transparency

Implement E-FOIA’s Public Index Requirement to Start Making Sense of the Government’s Information Holdings

Identify Disclosure Priorities Using FOIA Trends

Require Agencies to Affirmatively Disclose Information to the Public, as Mandated by E-FOIA

The administration should curb new exemptions from FOIA

Empower the National Archives and Records Adminstration to enforce the JFK Records Act

To Make FOIA Work, Costs of Non-Disclosure Must Be Greater than Benefits

Revise OPM Report to Direct Changes in Personnel Policies for FOIA Professionals

Opening our past, cutting secrecy at the source

Promote Open Government and Protect Privacy

Automatic Saving and Storage of E-mails and other Electronic Records in their Original Format

Time to update the Freedom of Information Act

Sunset all classified /non FOIA information

Frequent FOIA on web site

FOIA Tracking System

Activity Chart
Controversy Meter
Idea Rank : 312