I agree
Voting is Disabled

116 votes

I disagree

Rank257

Idea#178

This idea is active.
Uncategorized »

An educated populace is necessary for good government

Why Is This Idea Important?: One must prioritize activity in terms of importance. Emphasizing the structure before the means and capability of using it is placing the cart before the horse.

As was observed by both Plato and Aristotle 2500 years ago, an educated population is necessary for democratic processes to work. Simply establishing machinery for access to decision makers is not enough. To achieve the goal of an educated population, one must reconstitute the school system. This means establishing a mandatory curriculum that includes philosophy and critical thinking at all levels. Getting people to participate in decision making always has been a serious problem, as people are so concerned with the every day minutiae of their lives. Too, one must ask at what level and to what degree should they participate. Government is so large and often overwhelming. The mechanics outlined on this website help, but, again, education must come first.

Submitted by Unsubscribed User 2 years ago

Vote Activity Show

Comments (11)

  1. Unsubscribed User said:

    One of the great problems with our current k-12 school system is a lack of accountability of our teachers, and I'm not talking about student grades or state level assessment test scores. There is no accountability for *what* is being taught, or how, or when.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  2. Unsubscribed User said:

    I would also suggest that we pay attention to higher education. Currently the funding for the humanities and social sciences is being severely cut, largely because these parts of the university are not seen as "profitable" enterprises. However, it is in the humanities and social sciences that students have the space to learn civic engagement, critical thinking, the ability to make, hold and defend ideals as well as a flexibility in thinking. If we continue to watch the liberal arts be dismantled we will see the further decaying of an engaged and educated public sphere that can engage in lively political debate. The federal government could go a long way to pump money and resources into universities that are now on highly fluctuating state funding, private donations and skyrocketing tuition.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  3. Unsubscribed User said:

    Good point, but you do not specify how we can achieve that goal or how it relates to open government. Here are some suggestions in terms of process.

    - Allow states to create textbooks like the California Open Textbook Project. Doing this will turn textbook costs into revenue for the state and content in the books will be aligned with curriculum standards.

    See: http://www.opensourcetext.org/

    - Another way to ensure an educated populace is to eliminate social problems that act as a barrier to learning. The proposal for Promise Neighborhoods modeled after the Harlem Children Zone has the potential to make full-service community schools a reality. Transparency and collaboration could help schools identify partners, manage finances, and clear up governance issues.

    See: http://www.communityschools.org/

    -Reinvigorate clearinghouses like ERIC from the department of education, but in a more strategic way. By gathering state data the department of education can assess and disseminate best practices nationwide in a more effective manner. Something similar to this was eliminated during the Reagan administration and recently re-proposed in a research paper by Suzanne Donovan entitled “How People Learn: Bridging Research and Practice”

    See: http://eric.ed.gov/ERICDocs/data/ericdocs2sql/content_storage_01/0000019b/80/16/29/56.pdf

    Is this along the lines of how you thought this goal of educating the populace could be achieved? Please elaborate on how this process could be achieved by greater transparency and citizen participation.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  4. go2thesun said:

    As it was observed by lil ole me, homeless and multi- disabled in 2007,we have too many beavis and butthead voters who rely on one liners to make political choices.

    ONE CLASS on critical thinking/logic should be required for HS graduation;

    ONE CLASS on voting and current politics.USA and foreign. (Each student must debate both sides of a current issue);

    ONE CLASS on basic life skills, all should be mandatory.

    We must prepare our youth in an ever more complex and competitive world.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  5. klpetrak said:

    Let us not be naive and expect that everyone will be educated to the same, or "sufficient" level. There will be inevitably differences in the level of education. How do you propose to deal with that? Are you proposing an "acceptable level" of educations?

    Greeks dealt with this by letting only "free men", i.e., people of property (no slaves or women) to participate in "open government" (as represented by Agora). Obviously we cannot do that, so my question remains - who is educated "well enough". I do believe that there should be a technocratic element in our open government with a clearly defined roles and responsibilities.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  6. Love your post. Jefferson said a nation's best defense is an educated citizenry, and Madison said that a populace that means to govern itself must be informed.

    See Open Source Agency for an implementing idea that embraces your own.

    Earth Intelligence Network is the 501c3 Public Charity created to pursue public intelligence in the public interest.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  7. nancy.thomas said:

    Fund education for a transparent, participatory, collaborative, and just government.

    The beneficiaries should be secondary school students, college and university students, and everyday citizens who are not currently enrolled in school.

    Funding should support curricular and co-curricular development and reform. We need to assess existing programs in history, social studies, and civics at the secondary school level to determine what students are learning, and change what doesn't work. We need to hold schools accountable for meeting these expectations.

    Colleges and universites can be critical partners in this work. All students (not just those who study political science) should graduate knowing democracy's core principles and practices: Constitutional ideals, US history and ongoing struggles for civil rights, political processes, skills for public participation and problem solving, an interdisciplinary examination of critical public issues and current events, intercultural communication, and so forth.

    Colleges and universities can also play a critical role in educating the broader public. They can convene public forums on critical issues, including things that tend to divide us as a nation: race, gender, class, religion, national origin, and political ideology. They can offer continuing education courses in government and social change. They can offer certificate programs in public dialogue, community organizing, conflict resolution, and facilitative leadership. They can provide continuing education to government employees on transparency, citizen participation, and interagency collaboration.

    Our schools, colleges, and universities should be supported in their efforts to build an "informed" citizenry.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  8. Make education more transparent to achieve the goal of an educated populace by finding out what is really happening in schools. Do not base decision making on assumptions or merely talks with administrators.We assume kids read in school. In actuality,middle school students only read 20 minutes a day in school by some accounts.Those with good home situations read even more at home. Many disadvantaged students can't read at home due to circumstances beyond their control, and then they are not given enough time to read in school to improve their skills. Many teachers don't understand the power of reading to build better readers, vocabulary, or even writing skills.

    English is a phonetic code. We are a land of immigrants. It is surprising that many middle and high school teachers do not know how to teach phonetics and these students don't get what they need to access our language. (As a teacher I use Reading Reflex as a simple, effective method.)

    We know longer teach keyboarding at our middle school.The higher ups assume kids now know how to type. They all don't, especially the disadvantaged and special ed. Consider making a mandatory keyboarding skills test for a certain grade -- sixth grade??

    We want our students to protect our environment. Help them to love the land so they will protect the land. Eliminate field trips to the movies, etc.

    Start language learning in elementary school. Students can have a native accent if they learn before puberty. They then have the confidence to excel in our goal of having an educated populace.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  9. It should be opt-out, and should start in third grade, but otherwise that's potentially a good idea.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  10. sobi said:

    When is the last time you took a philosophy class?

    Barf.

    I'll go with critical thinking though.

    2 years ago
    0
    0
  11. problem is what philosophy and what thinking?? When you educate someone in philosophy and how to think, you also teach them What to think and thus how to vote--this is why education gets so politicized. Probably best to learn the 3R's and have an idea of how government processes work without being indoctrinated in any philosophy by a government run school.

    2 years ago
    0
    0