Open Government Dialogue
« Back To OpenGov - Open Government Brainstorm
Make the IRS auditors open and accountable to citizens
The IRS is the opposite of an open government. They operate in a "we are always right" fashion and are nearly impossible to get help from. They have been created for a purpose to collect money for the people to help our nation of the people. However, they forgot along the way that the same people they treat with indifference and as a number are those that they are working for.

First, the IRS should not deploy an assumption that every citizen is guilty until they themselves prove their own innocence. While this might be an efficient manner to operate within, this is providing a disservice to the citizen selected for examination. This does also mean that automated notices should be done away with. For example, some citizens get an automated notice that all of their charitable contributions are discarded and invalid along with the paperwork to pay the back taxes and fines associated with those contributions. The citizen was assumed guilty and they are able to try to prove their innocence by sending in their paperwork.

Second, the IRS should work in as efficient and open of a process as they expect the citizens to be. For example, upon being audited the IRS expects the citizen to return documentation within 30 days by mail or fax. However, they are "not able to" confirm the receipt of that information for 3 weeks let alone respond to it. Websites and interactions to check on the status of the information should be available.

Third, the IRS should allow for open communication to the people who can actually help. Upon being audited, many citizens are pointed to a toll free number they can call and talk to a representative that has nothing to do with the audit itself. This is not open and is also a disservice to citizens.

Finally, the IRS should allow for an open way to give feedback on a particular auditor's performance. If an auditor was being unreasonable, there should be an open process to complain about an auditor. For example, if an auditor is being rude or insensitive to a citizen, they should have the right to easily file a complaint and have that complaint responded to.

Why Is This Idea Important?

The IRS is a service for the US citizens that they pay for. They then persecute many innocent citizens and treat them poorly without any recourse. They demand a lot of information but do not return any when needed. A citizen cannot get real status of their audit or talk to the person actually conducting the audit. A citizen also has no way to provide feedback about the IRS auditor. This is not how an open government should work.
Comments
balanor 9 months ago
An IRS audit is no different than a cop pulling you over for a broken taillight. Said cop/auditor is not interested in the taillight. He's a human with aspirations of greater things like bonuses and promotions and boondoggle travel revenue. Cop/auditor is there to poke indiscriminately into your life in order to find unknown goodies like drugs in the trunk or unreported revenues. The average JoeBlow taxpayer doesn't make enough mistakes to justify the invasion by the cop/auditor, but Congress will never know as any government agency worth its existence is going to cook the numbers knowing that only outside intervention by professionals will "find them out", but that won't happen as Congress won't pay to uncover the deceit...preferring to increase the budgets every year for these floundering agencies.
IRS doesn't work....never did work fairly and needs serious reorganization starting with the discovery and removal of incompetent management.

YES! as with many government agencies, the scum at the bottom of the barrel breaks off, rises through the brilliant milk and settles at the top like the spoiled cream that is management.

Like the blind pied piper leading the kids off the cliff, management in IRS joyfully leads and steps aside while the kids fall into the abyss.
skidadsr 9 months ago
Just abolish the IRS. End of problems...
brown.jean 9 months ago
Simplified tax laws would prevent a lot of this abuse.
politisal 9 months ago
In defense of IRS auditors (not a popular position, generally) my family's accountant (now retired) started as an IRS auditor before going into private practice. Knowing him personally I'm sure he was fair, respectful, and honest. That being said, he's of an older generation, and a lot then was more fair, respectful, and honest. However, our accountant's son has taken over the business and is just as good—he was brought up by good parents. On the whole, however, the IRS is a typical, probably worse than average, bureaucracy, which is less helpful than it could be, to say the least, and definitely use intimidation. It certainly needs oversight.
bradley.will 9 months ago
The IRS website, along with most other agency websites, needs a major redesign.

A simple "here's your forms, fill them out online, push submit, and if you need to check the status or get help just login to irs.gov" would be revolutionary. Sorry TurboTax, the IRS is web2.0 now.
pecohen 9 months ago
Although I voted for this proposal, I'm not sure it is the most important issue relating to the IRS.

Years ago (maybe 35 years ago, in the pre-Reagan era), most of the IRS's focus and use of its auditing resources was devoted to big cases that would yield the biggest returns. It may be that this was also where the most cheating occurs.

However, over time the emphasis has been shifted to the little guy, possibly because the little guy lacks the resources to put up a fight in court. Maybe what we need is legal reform to level the playing field so that the little guy has a chance to get some traction in court.
Debra Bryant 9 months ago
Want to see the surplus money the US government and all states, local governments have? http://CAFR1.com and http://TaxRetirement.com
and support Campaign for Liberty
cashman57 9 months ago
Regarding that issue, when the IRS lost in its action against Tommy Cryer they set a precedent.
If all Americans were familiar with U.S. v Cryer we would have an IRS that is polite.
Cryer is seeking compensation from the government regarding the violations of privacy he has accused the IRS of.
Debra Bryant 9 months ago
Surplus money: Google CAFR1 then you will see where the money is. also called The Biggest Game in Town.
Debra Bryant 9 months ago
Do a search in Google on "Government Wealth" then if you are inclined, support this man that has provided this great service for us that make up the USA. We need volunteers to audit their city, county, state, etc...
gypsy_sage 9 months ago
You know they are really working for the Federal Reserve bankers don t you....thats what I always heard growing up
Twitchy 9 months ago
I agrre with brown.jean. A major part of the problem is our byzantine tax laws.

However, probably the only practical solution is to junk the whole system and move to something like the FairTax,
Related Topics/Ideas
Title






































Activity Chart
Controversy Meter
Idea Rank : 51